<ruby id="xvx5v"></ruby>

        <p id="xvx5v"><mark id="xvx5v"></mark></p>

        <p id="xvx5v"></p>

          巴黎人检测826

          Home Today's Paper Most Popular Video Gallery Photo Gallery
          Subscription Blog Signin Register
          Logo
          Saturday, June 13, 2020 09:36:33 PM
          Follow Us On: Facebook Twitter Twitter Twitter Twitter

          Negotiable Instruments Act 138A

          Appeal invalid against sentence unless 50pc cheque amount deposited

          By
          21st-Mar-2020       
          Share
          • Twitter
          • Google+
          • Save
          • E-mail
          • Print
          Comments
          Share your thought
          Post a comment ?
          Read all () ?

          High Court Division
          (Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)

          Md. Badruzzaman J

          Abdul Kader (Md) alias Karim …..
          ……………….Convict-Appellant
          ??????????????????? vs
          State…………opposite-Party
          Judgment
          June 13th, 2019
          Negotiable Instruments Act (XXVI of 1881)
          Section 138A
          Since the Act is a special law providing special procedure for filing appeal in Section 138A of the Act by overriding the provisions of the CrPC.
          ............But in Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 no such provision has been inserted for compromise of any dispute. Since Negotiable Instruments Act is a special law providing special procedure for filing appeal in Section 138A of the Act ay overriding the provisions of the CrPC in this regard, this Court is of the view that the decision of the case of 38 DLR (AD) 38 is not applicable in the? case….. (12)
          Abdus Sattar vs State, 38 DLR (AD) 38 and Md. Joynal vs Md Rustam Ali Mia, 1984 (AD) 29 ref.
          Sk Zulfiqllr Bulbul Chowdhury, Advocate-For the Convict-Appellaant.
          Md. Atiqul Hoque (Salim), AAG-For the State.
          Judgment
          Md Badruzzaman J : This appeal under Section 410 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, at the instance of convict appellant, is directed against judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 25-11-2018 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, 3rd Court, Chottagram in Sessions Case No. 1691 of 2018 arising out of CR Case No. 84 of 2018 (Rangunia) convicting the appellant under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and sentencing him there under to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 4 (four) months with a fine of Taka 15,00,000.
          2. Short facts are that respondent No.2 as complainant filed petition of complaint before the concerned Magistrate against the convict-appellant under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 stating that the convict issued a cheque dated 12-11-2017 in favour of the complainant for an amount of Taka 12,00,000 against loan which was dishonored for insufficiency of fund when the same was placed for encashment on 23-1-2018. Thereafter, the complainant published a notice in the "Dainik Shangram" on 14-2-2018 asking the appellant for payment of the said amount but he failed to do so and hence the case.
          3. The learned Magistrate initially took cognizance against the appellant under the aforesaid section of law and issued summons against the appellant. The appellant voluntarily surrendered before the learned Magistrate and obtained bail. Thereafter, the case was transferred to the learned Sessions Judge who also took cognizance. Eventually, trial was held in absentia and the trial Court convicted and sentenced the appellant as stated above. Then the appellant was arrested and taken into custody on 27-3-2019.
          4. It is stated in the petition of appeal that after his arrest, the dispute between the appellant and respondent No. 2 has been settled out of Court and as per the settlement, the appellant paid all dues to the complainant and the complainant filed an application on 16-5-2019 before the trial Court stating that the complainant would have no objection if the appellant is released on bail. Accordingly, the appellant filed an application for bail on the same date on 16-5-2019 which was rejected by the trial Court on the ground that the appellant did not deposit 50% of the cheque amount for preferring an appeal.
          5. Thereafter, this appeal has been preferred without depositing 50% of the cheque amount and with a delay of 123 days. However, on the prayer of the learned Advocate for the appellant this Bench vide order dated 27-5-2019 permitted to file the appeal provisionally and vide order dated 12-6-19 condoned the said delay with a direction to the office to register the appeal and accordingly, the same has been registered. Now this matter has been placed before this Court for admission hearing.
          6. Mr Sk Zulfiqur Bulbul Chowdhury, learned Advocate appearing for the convict-appellant in support of Admission of appeal submits that after pronouncement of the impugned judgment and the arrest of the convict appellant the dispute between the complainant and the appellant has been settled out of Court and as per said settlement, the appellant has paid entire dues of the com-plainant who also received the same followed by an application to the Court below and accordingly, requirement of depositing 50% of the cheque amount for filing appeal under Section 138A of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 has been fulfilled and as such, this appeal should be admitted without depositing 50% of the cheque amount. In support of his contention learned Advocate has placed a decision of the case of Abdus Sattar vs State, reported in 38 DLR (AD) 38 and submits that in the said case the Appellate Division allowed compromise before it and considering the said view this Court should allow the compromise in the instant case.
          7. I have heard the learned Advocate and perused the records.
          8. Before going into the facts of the case it would be beneficial to look into the relevant provisions of law regarding this matter. Section 138A of the Negotiable Instruments Act has imposed a restriction in respect of appeal against any order of sentence passed under sub-Section (1) of Section 138 of the said Act which stipulates as follows:
          " 138A. Notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Criminal Procedure 1918, no appeal against any order of sentence under sub-section (1) of Section 138 shall lie, unless an amount of not less than fifty per cent of the amount of the dishonored cheque is deposited before filing the appeal in the Court which awarded the sentence."
          9. Section '138A' has been inserted in Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 by Section 3 of the Negotiable Instruments (Amendment) Act, 2006 (Act No. III of 2006.The provision of Section 138A is clear and unambiguous. By inserting Section 138A in the original NI Act, 1881 the Parliament has intentionally made a bar in preferring an appeal against any order of sentence under sub-Section (1) of Section 138. By using the words "notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898" and the words "unless an amount of not less than fifty per cent of the amount of the dishonored cheque is deposited before filing the appeal in the Court which awarded the sentence" clearly suggest that the provisions of the code of criminal procedure in respect of preferring appeal under NI Act will not be applicable, and before filing the appeal 50% of the amount of the dishonored cheque is to be deposited in the Court which awarded the sentence. The Court which awarded the sentence specifically indicates that said amount must be deposited in the Court who awarded the sentence, nothing more nothing less inasmuch as that after awarding sentence under sub-Section (1) of Section 138, receipt of even total dues by the complainant from the convict will not fulfill the requirement of Section 138A of the NI Act.
          10. Since, Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 is a special law the provision of the said Act will prevail over the general law like the Code of Criminal Procedure and since Section 138A of the NI Act, 1881 imposed a precondition of depositing 50% of the cheque amount of the dishonored cheque in the court which awarded the sentence before filing an appeal against sentence under sub-Section (1) of Section 138 of the said Act with a consequence that without? such deposition, no appeal shall lie this Court is of the view that no appellate court have got jurisdiction? to waive such pre-condition or entertain? any such appeal and/or accept any compromise which has been held before filing of appeal.

          11. I have carefully perused the judgment of the Appellate Division reported in 38 DLR (AD) 38. In the said case initially conviction under Section 379 of the Penal Code was passed by the trial Court against the appellant. The appeal was dismissed by the Appellate Court.? The accused moved revision under Section 439A CrPC before the Sessions Judge which was dismissed whereupon, the accused filed an application under Section 561A CrPC for the proceeding which was dismissed, High Court Division, Thereafter, the accused filed Criminal Petition for Special Leave to Appeal with a petition under Section 345 of CrPC for compounding the offence before the Appellate Division, and the Appellate Division granted leave and appeal was registered. The Appellate Division in the said case? relied its earlier decision of the case of Md. Joynal vs? Md Rustam Ali Mia, reported in Bangladesh Case Reports 1984 (AD) 29 wherein it was held that "our criminal administration of justice encourages compromise of certain disputes and some of the cases can be compounded? as provided by Section 345 CrPC" . By endorsing the same view the appellate Division allowed compromise by acquitting the accused holding as follows:
          "Section ?? ?379, ?? ?Penal ?? ?Code ?? ?is compoundable by the owner of the property stolen. Mrs. Jobeda Khatun is the complainant and is the owner of the property in question. She has now filed an affidavit praying for composition of the offence as the parties are inter-related. As we have noticed that the law encourages the compromise of the offence and since this matter is pending by way of special leave before this Court, we have no hesitation in allowing the composition and as a result this composition shall have the effect of acquittal of the accused."
          12. It appears that the said case was initiated under the Penal Code and there was no requirement of depositing any amount for filing appeal before the appellate Court. More so, the compromise was allowed in that case considering the provision of Section 345 CrPC which empowers the Court to allow compromise of certain disputes. But in Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 no such provision has been inserted for compromise of any dispute. Since Negotiable Instruments Act is a special law providing special procedure for filing appeal in Section 138A of the said Act by overriding the provisions of the CrPC in this regard, this Court is of the view that the decision of the case of 38 DLR (AD) 38 is not applicable in the instant case.
          13. In the instant case this appeal has been preferred without depositing 50% of the amount of the dishonored cheque in the trial Court who awarded the sentence as per provision under Section 138A of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. In view of the legal position as discussed above this appeal is not maintainable for admission and as such, the same should be dismissed.
          Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed summarily.

          Tariff
          Add Rate

          News Archive

          Inside The New Nation

          Editorial »

          Huge deficit financing makes the budget unrealistic


          THE proposed budget for 2020-21 is a huge expenditure programme at a cost of Tk 5.65 trillion with a deficit of Tk 1,90,000 crore which is over 6 percent of the GDP and invariably signals the redline in fiscal discipline. Budgetary deficit is usually tolerable at 5 percent level.The Finance ...

          City »

          RAB-2 personnel nabbed two drug peddlers with private car and hemp from the city's Dhanmondi area on Friday.


          Business & Economy »

          Md Ataur Rahman Prodhan, Managing Director and CEO of Sonali Bank Ltd and Dr Ashis Kumar Chakraborti, Managing Director of Universal Medical College and Hospital, exchanging Documents after signing a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) to ensure corporate health services at the bank's head office in the city on Thursday. Priti Chakraborti, CIP, Chairman of the Medical College and Director of FBCCI, was also present.


          Business & Economy »

          Australia won't be 'intimidated' amid China economic threats: PM


          Australia warned Thursday it would not be intimidated by attempts at economic "coercion" after China threatened to undermine the multi-billion dollar flow of Chinese tourists and students to the country.Beijing has issued warnings in recent days that Chinese should avoid Australia due to concerns about racist incidents targeting ethnic Asians ...

          Health »

          Happiness & Sorrows Go on pacing with highest acceleration ever


          Ramisa Maliha Bhuiyan :Your ephemeral life is a blender of mind refreshing news, heart rending incidents and heart soothing remarks. There are some stages of mankind which are as follows: The final stage is going to the darkest place forever- the grave. Here is the end of such a short, ...

          Football »

          La Liga resumes after three months away as Sevilla defeat Betis


          Sevilla beat local rivals Real Betis 2-0 as La Liga returned after three months away on Thursday, becoming the second of Europe's five major leagues to resume following the coronavirus pandemic.After the Bundesliga in Germany restarted on May 16, La Liga opened its doors again to players but not supporters ...

          Cricket »

          Gascoigne in China: 'I miss him so much', says ex-coach


          England maverick Paul Gascoigne was playing a friendly match against Chinese media when he abruptly sat down, conjured a toothbrush from his sock and began cleaning his teeth.It was classic Gazza-the brilliant, joke-loving but troubled midfielder memorably labelled "daft as a brush" by his former England manager Bobby Robson.Gong Lei ...

          Entertainment »

          Vidya makes nostalgic with some pics from the sets of Parineeta on its 15th anniversary


          Piyu Bole! Piya Bole! Kya yeh bole jaanu na, remember the heart winning chartbuster from Bollywood’s much celebrated film Parineeta featuring the versatile Vidya Balan and Saif Ali Khan along with Sanjay Dutt and Raima Sen in pivotal roles. Pradeep Sarkar’s adaptation of Sarat Chandra Chattopadhayay’s Lolita into Parineeta was ...

          Entertainment »

          Ovi Moinuddin coming with own composed song


          Entertainment Report :Music was his fascination during childhood. Born in Moddhyonogor Bazar of Sunamganj journalist Ovi Moinuddin got appreciation rendering song on the stage when he was student of Sylhet Cadet College and University of Dhaka. He received training from Ustad Ram Kanai Das under coordination of his cadet college ...

          City »

          Bangladesh Juba Shakti formed a human chain in front of the Jatiya Press Club on Friday demanding special allocation for unemployed youths in the national budget.


          Editorial »

          Unless looting businesses is stopped budget is no hope for the people


          FINANCE Minister AHM Mustafa Kamal announced the areas and mode of untaxed money investment as he placed the budget in parliament on June 11 for the 2020-2021 fiscal starting from July 1.But this is not the best of years to place big budgets. In fact with the World Bank stating ...

          City »

          Information Minister Dr. Hasan Mahmud speaking at a Milad Mahfil marking the Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina's Jail Release Day at the AL President's Political Office in the city's Dhanmondi area on Thursday.


          .

          Entertainment »

          Shahnoor returns shooting after three months lockdown


          Entertainment Report :After lockdown at her home for three months at a time viewers’ choice film actress Shahnoor has returned to acting. She started shooting of upcoming Eid special drama titled Bou Bari, which is being directed by Sadeque Siddiqui, at Priyanka Shooting House in the capital’s Eskaton area. Shahnoor ...

          Football »

          Lewandowski fires weary Bayern into German Cup final in double bid


          AFP, Munich :Bayern Munich remain on course for the double after the Bundesliga leaders squeezed past Eintracht Frankfurt 2-1 in Wednesday's German Cup semi-final behind closed doors, with both teams supporting the Black Lives Matter movement.Bayern's early goal by Ivan Perisic was cancelled out by a second-half equaliser from Frankfurt's ...

          Editorial »

          Use of stimulus package must be saved from corruption


          SPEAKERS at a dialogue on Tuesday have rightly laid emphasis on cautious use of stimulus package money to help affected trade and industry saying failure to ensure its proper utilization will largely leave its achievements unfulfilled. Mainly they have said big defaulters should not benefit from it because it will ...

           
          Items that you save may be read at any time on your computer, iPad, iPhone or Android devices.
           
          Are you new to our website? Do you have already an account at our website?
          Create An Account Log in here
          Email this news to a friend or like someone
          Email:
          Write a comment to this news

          巴黎人检测826